London, November 19, 2026
Effective negotiators aren’t born. Katherine Edgecombe and Richard Jones of The GAP Partnership, explain why the best negotiators plan for things to go wrong, manage their emotions in the room, adapt their style, and think beyond the headline numbers.
Planning for failure
It can seem a strange idea for high achievers who are used to succeeding. But planning for failure is a core part of how The Gap Partnership (TGP) prepare for a complex negotiation.
“Typically, when we approach a more complex negotiation, we’ll initially assess the situation,” says Richard. We’ll consider whether a more competitive or collaborative stance is appropriate, how we intend to manage value – whether to take, share or give – and where the balance of power sits. Together, these factors helps us to determine our lead negotiation strategy.”
In an ideal world, that lead strategy succeeds. On occasion, it doesn’t work as expected. So TGP sets triggers in advance that move a negotiator from a lead strategy to a contingent approach, which will often involve a different set of behaviours and proposals. If that doesn’t work either, a further trigger moves them to a third contingent strategy.
“Fundamentally, what we’re trying to do is look into the future, identify issues, problems and challenges, front-load all of those decisions, and then preempt those challenges by thinking about contingent approaches that will hopefully be successful,” says Richard.
Katherine explains why this matters. “With the best will in the world and all the planning in the world, inevitably you’re going to hit bumps in the road. Anything to do with negotiation means there is conflict: two parties are not in agreement. If you haven’t already thought through what you’re going to do when you hit that bump, this is where emotions come into the room, and decisions can be made which are not the most strategic.”
That is why, when TGP works with clients on strategic planning, it is key to play through every possible scenario:
- What happens if you hit a bump in the road?
- What are the trigger points?
- When do you move to plan B?
- What would set you off to plan C?
“The key thing is that this will only work if everybody is bought into the plan in advance,” says Katherine. “Internal alignment on any of these approaches is absolutely key. You’ve always got to plan from the perspective that it would be an unusual negotiation that was a smooth ride through high levels of complexity where the stakes are high.”
Strategy versus tactics
GAP looks at negotiation from two perspectives. Strategic negotiation is the preparation done ahead of time, sometimes 6 to 12 months in advance: the lead approach, the contingent plans, and front-loading decisions. Tactical negotiation is what happens in the room: how you behave, the questions you ask, the proposals you build, and the trades and moves you make.
As Richard puts it, tactics are often experienced as the “emotional rollercoaster of a live negotiation, where pressure, behaviours and decisions all come into play.”
You’ve done all your preparation, then you get in the room and suddenly there are feelings to deal with. For Katherine, the ability to manage your emotions, or at least understand what behaviours they drive, is essential for an effective negotiator.
Emotions and how they influence negotiation
“Even the word emotion is a funny one, because immediately it draws connotations of bursting into tears or having an over-the-top reaction,” she says. “But we are emotional beings, and we need to recognise that in negotiation there is always going to be conflict. However well planned you are, that will drive certain emotions.”
This is not gender-specific. TGP’s research found that over a third of men worried about coming across as too emotional. “For all the people I’ve worked with, this is definitely not a gender-specific thing, because emotions can drive all sorts of inappropriate behaviours,” says Katherine.
Stay conscious, stay in control
The answer is to be conscious. “If the way you behave is driven by your emotions, you’re not in control. You’re allowing your subconscious to control you,” says Katherine. “Ideally, you want to be conscious of everything you do and everything you say. It’s all about being planned, prepared, strategic and conscious.”
That doesn’t mean becoming someone else. “This is about being authentically you, but it’s about being conscious. Which version of yourself is showing up at this meeting? How are you reacting when they say something you don’t like? Is it your emotion driving you to behave in a certain way, or can you take a pause, a breath, think about it, and react in a conscious, more appropriate way?”
She speaks from experience. “I’ve been in many meetings where things happen that make me feel extremely emotional. But what am I going to do with those emotions? Am I going to let them drive what I do next? Or am I going to stay conscious that it is happening within me? I don’t need it to affect how I make my next move.”
When you’re too close
Richard adds that emotion is often driven by discomfort with the situation, perceived conflict, or by being too close to what’s being negotiated.
“If I’m negotiating the purchase of a house, and my wife is telling me this is the one and the kids love it, there’s a huge amount of emotional pressure on me to negotiate a favourable deal whilst keeping my family happy, because they don’t care what it costs. They just want the house.”
That’s often why TGP is brought in. “Not because we know the sector better than the people involved, but because we’re not emotionally attached to what we’re talking about,” says Richard. “We provide the rigour, the process, the guidance, the coaching and the support, from an impartial perspective.”
The five keys to negotiation style
There are many types and styles of negotiation, but broadly they can be categorised as competitive or collaborative. Competitive deals are short-term and transactional. Collaborative negotiations are longer-term relationships built on working together.
Five key factors tell you which one you’re in, and shape how people behave.
- Relationship: Is there an existing relationship, or an opportunity to build one?
- Trust: What level of trust is required to conduct the negotiation? Do you need to build it or protect it?
- Dependency: What options does each party have? These are often called BATNAs: the best alternative to a negotiated agreement.
- Complexity: How many variables are up for negotiation?
The fifth and final consideration is Power, whether real or perceived. Whilst the nature of the relationship, the need for trust, levels of dependency and complexity help shape our behaviours and inform the type of negotiation we face, power determines how much influence we have over the process. Put simply, the greater your power, the more control you have over how the negotiation unfolds.
| Factor | Competitive negotiation | Collaborative negotiation |
| Relationship | No existing relationship to protect | A longer-term relationship to build or protect |
| Trust | Low threshold; parties can deal without any trust at all | Significant trust required, often from years of working together |
| Dependency | Both parties have lots of other options, so tenders, auctions and RFPs are common | Fewer options; both parties need or want to work together |
| Complexity | Narrow, often one primary variable: a price, fee, margin, budget or liability cap | Broad: 10, 20, 30 or even 500 variables to play with |
Why complexity matters most
When a negotiation is fixated on one variable, it’s almost impossible to collaborate. “Because there’s such a low level of complexity, people try to use their behaviours to force conformity rather than being creative,” says Richard.
With lots of variables, some will matter more to one side than the other. “This allows you to link those variables, trade concessions and drive a mutually beneficial outcome,” he says.
Katherine warns that people often misread this. “People automatically think they’re working in a long-term relationship, so this must be a collaborative discussion. But if you’re only negotiating over price/fees, even if you’ve worked with this person many times, it’s actually a hard bargain. That is a tough competitive negotiation. Your mindset needs to change, because if you approach it with a collaborative mindset, you’re potentially not going to get the optimum outcome.”
What you measure is what you get
According to Richard, the biggest influence on behaviour is how people are measured, not their gender. TGP compared 5,000 men and 5,000 women across the world against the 14 behaviours of what it defines as the complete negotiator. Perceived capability was almost identical. The one marked difference was listening, where women scored higher.
“We work with some really assertive men, and likewise some pretty assertive women. We work with some very passive men and some very passive women,” says Richard. “If you’re measuring people short term on a small number of variables, their ability to be creative is reduced, and they try to change their behaviour to force the other party into conformity. If you’re measuring people longer term over a broader array of variables, they’ll be more creative, collaborative and empathetic.”
Flexibility wins
Most people would rather work collaboratively, because more value can come out of those discussions. But it takes two to tango.
“There’s no definitive silver bullet,” says Richard. “There’s not one particular style that always drives a successful outcome. The most accomplished negotiators we work with are the most flexible in the way that they behave.”
Katherine agrees. “If I recognise that somebody on the other side of the table is only measured on hitting a certain number, there’s no point killing myself trying to create a collaborative outcome. I’m going to dial that side of my brain down, focus on the best I can do with limited creativity, and just get the job done.”
And if you walk in expecting collaboration and meet the opposite? “Potentially you haven’t done your planning in the right way,” says Katherine. “By the time you go into the meeting, you should already be very well aware of the environment you’re going into, and have done everything you can to precondition the other party.”
How to negotiate a higher salary
Richard and Katherine have delivered many sessions for Level 20, and one question always comes up at the end: how do I negotiate a better salary?
“I’m not surprised,” says Katherine. “We’re all aware there’s still a gender pay gap.”
Get inside the other party’s head
At one session, a very senior person involved in hiring was in the room. Their perspective echoed what TGP always teaches: as part of your planning, think inside the other party’s head.
“When it comes to salary, it’s very easy to get inside your own head and think about what you want, what you need, or that you’re never going to get it. Am I worth it? Am I getting as much as them?” says Katherine. “But you’ve got to think about what the other party wants. Why are you even at the table? What’s important to them? There must be things you bring that they value, or you wouldn’t be in the room.”
Look beyond the headline number
People tend to focus on the headline number, whether that’s annual salary or monthly pay. But a package has many other variables, and some are low cost to the employer and high value to you. Richard lists some of them:
- Time off
- Maternity or paternity leave
- Bonuses and incentives
- A company car
- Paid leave for professional development
- Healthcare
- Pension contributions
- Annual inflationary salary increases
Flexible working is a good example: letting you work four days instead of five may cost your employer little but be hugely valuable to you. “There are lots of other variables that can be negotiated that give you a better package without necessarily driving a headline number,” says Richard.
Transfer the onus
Richard has seen one approach work particularly well: the onus transfer.
“Sometimes people feel incredibly uncomfortable going to their boss and saying, I want a £10,000 increase, because it’s a unilateral demand that can create quite a negative vibe,” he says. “Instead, ask: what do I need to do to get a £10,000 increase on my salary? The onus is then on them to come up with the targets and KPIs you need to hit to achieve that goal, and you can hold them to account.”
Reframing the conversation this way makes it far more productive. It focuses on your development rather than a simple demand for more money.
-ENDS-
About Level 20
Level 20 is the leading industry body for women in private equity. Its mission is to increase the representation of senior women, particularly in investment roles. Through professional networking, career development, research & insight and industry engagement, Level 20 supports individuals and firms in building inclusive and high performing teams. The organisation has 8,500 members and operates across 20 countries in 13 European chapters. Level 20 membership is free and open to both men and women. To learn more, visit: Level20.org.